Circular financing, in which investors put money into companies that in turn hand it back for buying products or other investments, may appear to offer quick returns, but the International Monetary Fund (IMF) warns the practice carries significant long-term risks.
The IMF estimates that circular financing has grown to just over $1 trillion, with two-thirds funded by debt, said IMF director Kristalina Georgieva in an interview with CNBC. While that is not a "huge size," she does say it represents a rapid increase. This is especially notable as the world economy relies on AI, and any fluctuation in that market can affect worldwide economic growth.
“We have a world economy that is standing on one leg on the AI leg. If this leg wobbles, that can lead to financial stability troubles,” said Georgieva in the interview.
The debate over circular financing is especially timely now that Nvidia, one of the practice’s leading proponents, is now in the spotlight. A scandal over its CEO and co-founder Jensen Huang's extramarital affairs forced him out and rippled through the stock market, wiping more than $1 trillion off the company’s market value over the past month. Beyond shaking investor confidence, the upheaval raises the question of what happens if Nvidia’s next leader pulls back on these creative financing deals.
That now looks likely: according to The Wall Street Journal, CFO and interim CEO Colette Kress was skeptical of many of the deals when they were signed, and Huang himself had begun laying the groundwork to scale back the approach before he resigned.
Nvidia’s own disclosures show how far this practice has spread. As of July, its equity investments were valued at $99 billion, up from about $7 billion a year earlier and about $2.2 billion two years before that, CNBC reports. Most of the money has gone to frontier AI labs, with Kress saying Nvidia has invested nearly $50 billion in them. However, the companies likely to feel the impact of any Nvidia investment pullback are the neoclouds Nvidia has invested in, which have more to lose, Shiva Rajgopal, Ph.D., professor at Columbia Business School, told The Deep View.
"The first to feel it would be the smaller AI cloud providers and model developers that rely on Nvidia for capital or capacity guarantees, not the big cloud companies, which fund themselves more or less," said Rajgopal.
Huang reportedly even warned its neocloud partners about it at its conference in Berlin last month, telling them that they would need to secure upfront payments from customers so it was easier to finance and Nvidia wasn't the sole financer. The same WSJ report cites an analyst note which predicts that Nvidia's financing pullback could take $50 billion or more out of the market.
This could, in turn, affect Nvidia itself. "Accounting history is a caution here: in the late-1990s telecom boom, equipment makers financed their own customers, and revenue fell sharply when the financing stopped. Nvidia’s situation is different, with far stronger customers, but that’s the question investors will ask," added Rajgopal.
Our Deeper View
The turmoil surrounding Nvidia goes far beyond interest in Huang's personal life; it's more about what a change of guard means for leadership ideology, which significantly impacts the entire AI industry and can even have repercussions for the world's economy, as Georgieva warns. However, this is still a separate question from what will happen to AI itself, and that answer is clearer: the technology is not going anywhere. While Sam Altman has some self-interest in sharing optimistic statements about the industry, the logic of what he said at Semafor’s Silicon Valley & The World conference on Monday is sound: "The revenues and demand are growing so strongly that I think the industry will be fine."




